Current:Home > Finance'Anatomy of a Fall' dissects a marriage and, maybe, a murder-InfoLens
'Anatomy of a Fall' dissects a marriage and, maybe, a murder
View Date:2024-12-23 15:03:03
One reason Sandra Hüller is one of the best actors working today, is that unlike many performers, she doesn't seem to care if you like her characters or not. Whether she's playing a tightly wound corporate climber in the brilliant comedy Toni Erdmann or a Nazi commandant's wife in the upcoming drama The Zone of Interest, you never once catch her pleading for the audience's sympathy.
That fearlessness is partly what makes her so compelling to watch in Anatomy of a Fall, the absorbingly intricate psychological thriller that won the Palme d'Or at Cannes this year. Hüller plays a successful German-born writer, also named Sandra, who finds herself on trial for her husband's murder.
The movie begins at a chalet in the French Alps, where Sandra and her French husband, Samuel, live with their 11-year-old son, Daniel. Things are tense between Sandra and Samuel, as we can sense from the way he blasts his music while she's being interviewed by a journalist. The interview gets cut short and the journalist leaves; sometime later, Samuel is found dead outside in the snow, bleeding heavily from a head wound.
Did he fall or jump from one of the chalet's upper stories? Or was he pushed? The director Justine Triet, who wrote the script with Arthur Harari, never reveals the answer. The story is full of intriguing forensic details; Samuel's fatal fall is diagrammed from every possible angle, and every spatter of blood is analyzed obsessively. But ultimately, Triet is less interested in explaining whodunit — or if anyone dun it — than in conducting an autopsy on Sandra and Samuel's marriage.
When Sandra is tried for Samuel's murder, the history of their troubled relationship comes to light. We learn that Samuel never forgave himself for his role in the accident years ago that left Daniel severely visually impaired. That took an obvious toll on the couple.
At one point, Samuel's therapist takes the stand and testifies that Samuel had described his wife as cold and controlling. But Sandra pushes back against this assessment, saying, "If I'd been seeing a therapist, he could stand here, too, and say very ugly things about Samuel. But would those things be true?"
I don't know how accurate Anatomy of a Fall is in its portrayal of the French legal system. But here, as in last year's excellent courtroom drama Saint Omer, it appears to be an extremely different system from ours, more tolerant of extended discussion. At one point, in a scene that even the movie seems to find hilarious, the overly aggressive prosecutor starts mining Sandra's own books for evidence, briefly turning a criminal trial into a literary debate. Still, Sandra's career is hardly incidental to the case. Samuel was also a writer, but a much less accomplished one than Sandra, which may have made him jealous.
Could Samuel have killed himself in despair? That's the possibility put forth to the court by Sandra's attorney — well played by Swann Arlaud — who doesn't seem entirely convinced of his client's innocence. Daniel, piercingly played by Milo Machado Graner, also doesn't know what to believe, as he's torn apart by the loss of his dad and possibly the loss of his mom.
The movie's emotional centerpiece is a stunningly written and acted flashback to a furious marital argument that took place shortly before Samuel's death — one of those knock-down, drag-out fights where every source of tension and resentment gets dragged to the surface. They clash over their finances, their differing approaches to parenting, their unsatisfying sex life and Sandra's past infidelity. Sandra expresses her frustration at the many sacrifices she's quietly made, including agreeing to live in France.
Anatomy of a Fall persuasively suggests that every marriage is ultimately something of a mystery. The fact that Samuel is no longer alive to defend himself makes it even harder to determine who here is telling the truth. Even so, I couldn't help but gravitate toward Sandra's side. There's something refreshing about the cool pragmatism she shows in the face of Samuel's insecurity, the way she refuses to short-change her career or coddle her husband for his failures. I left admiring Sandra's steely resolve, while still wondering if that resolve might have led her to do the unthinkable.
veryGood! (29984)
Related
- Tesla Cybertruck modifications upgrade EV to a sci-fi police vehicle
- Astrologer Susan Miller Reveals Her 2024 Predictions for Each Zodiac Sign
- Maurice Hines, tap-dancing icon and 'The Cotton Club' star, dies at 80
- Michigan giving 'big middle finger' to its critics with College Football Playoff run
- UFC 309: Jon Jones vs. Stipe Miocic fight card, odds, how to watch, date
- NFC playoff picture: San Francisco 49ers clinch home-field advantage
- Massive waves threaten California, coast braces for another round after Ventura rogue wave
- 2024 Winter Classic: Live stream, time, weather, how to watch Golden Knights at Kraken
- The charming Russian scene-stealers of 'Anora' are also real-life best friends
- Putin lauds Russian unity in his New Year’s address as Ukraine war overshadows celebration
Ranking
- Judge hears case over Montana rule blocking trans residents from changing sex on birth certificate
- AFC playoff picture: Baltimore Ravens secure home-field advantage
- Colorado mother suspected of killing her 2 children and wounding a third arrested in United Kingdom
- North Korea’s Kim orders military to ‘thoroughly annihilate’ US, South Korea if provoked
- The Daily Money: Inflation is still a thing
- See Martha Stewart's 'thirst trap' selfie showcasing luxurious nightgown
- After landmark legislation, Indiana Republican leadership call for short, ‘fine-tuning’ session
- 'Olive theory,' explained: The compatibility test based on 'How I Met Your Mother'
Recommendation
-
What do nails have to say about your health? Experts answer your FAQs.
-
The Baltimore Ravens are making a terrible mistake honoring Ray Rice. He's no 'legend'
-
Want a polar bear plunge on New Year's Day? Here's a deep dive on cold water dips
-
NFL Week 18 schedule set with game times for final Saturday, Sunday of regular season
-
Trump has promised to ‘save TikTok’. What happens next is less clear
-
Want a polar bear plunge on New Year's Day? Here's a deep dive on cold water dips
-
Consulting firm McKinsey agrees to $78 million settlement with insurers over opioids
-
The Detroit Pistons, amid a 28-game losing streak, try to avoid NBA history